| Rev. A. B. Lowes | October 1874 - December 1882 |
| Rev. Dr. Perrin Baker, D.D. | January 1883 - March 1923 |
| Rev. Stanley H. Jewel | November 1923 - May 1929 |
| Rev. Howard T. Curtiss | October 1929 - November 1935 |
| Rev. Dr. Edwin G. Sloan, PhD. | November 1936 - May 1943 |
| Rev. George L. Kress | July 1944 - October 1952 |
| Rev. S. George Clarke | September 1953 - June 1957 |
| Rev. Dr. S. Arthur Talman, PhD., D.D. | January 1958 - November 1978 |
| Rev. Charles D. LaPlaca | September 1979 - February 1990 |
| Rev. James D. Burton | July 1991 - July 1994 |
| Rev. James C. Ramsey | December 1996 - December 2003 |
| Rev. Suzanne Z. Currie | May 2006 - Present |
| |
| |
| |
